Flu Virus and Vaccination Misconceptions

Flu season is upon us. This brings up important questions for many people. This is because there are a great number of misconceptions about both the flu and its vaccination. Should you get the vaccine? Will you get the flu even after you have had the vaccine? Questions like these are common among those who live in areas in which the flu virus is prevalent. The flu is a common illness, but it is not one to be taken lightly. Influenza does, in fact, causes a pandemic every year. This is the case even in countries with advanced medical access like the USA. Furthermore, complications in treatment or further illness spurring from the original infection can cause more deaths to be added to the toll each year. With such a dangerous but misunderstood virus, how can we protect ourselves and those we love? The first step is understanding the virus. Once this is done, the vaccine can be understood and evaluated based on its effectiveness and manufacturing process. Influenza is a powerful virus, but we are not helpless against it.

flu-burden-cases-graphic
Figure 1: Shows the number of total cases of influenza infection in comparison to hospitalization and death count. [3]
The Influenza virus is transmitted to humans from certain types of animals. Most commonly, these are bird and swine species. Following the typical mechanism for a virus, influenza can be spread by contact. This can happen when someone infected with the virus coughs or sneezes, or when contact is made with the virus on a surface and then transmitted to the nose or mouth. This is the reason why covering your sneeze and cough are vital. Furthermore, sanitation of commonly used surfaces can also be beneficial as a preventative measure. The virus can be contagious before symptoms develop up until about a week after they start. This means you or others may be spreading the virus before you know you are sick. During flu season, whether you are aware that you are infected or not, it is vital to use precautionary measures to protect yourself and others.

The virus itself follows a normal virus’ life cycle. Once the virus has entered the body, it attacks specific cells. For the flu, the virus targets the epithelial cells in the respiratory tract. The virus then latches on to the plasma membrane of the cell and injects its genome into the cell. This makes the cell a host for the virus and effective factory for producing more viruses. The host cell starts producing and assembling the proteins that the virus requires. These new viruses assemble build up in the cell. Once the cell has produced enough viruses, the cell will burst, releasing the new viruses to spread to more cells in the epithelium.

The flu virus in particular is a very fluid virus in its ability to change. There are many mutations and combinations of proteins that make the flu hard to treat from year to year. In many cases, the flu virus that causes a pandemic one year is different from the one that was prevalent the previous year. The main proteins associated with influenza are hemagglutinin and neuraminidase. These proteins are transmembrane proteins that effect the identification of each virus. There are seventeen possible hemagglutinins and ten possible neuraminidases that can be incorporated into an influenza virus. This allows for a large range of influenza viruses that can be found and treated. In addition to the natural variability of the influenza virus, mutations in the genome can occur which makes the virus a different form than any form that had been previously known. The immense variability of the virus’ proteins make treating the flu very difficult, and makes it seemingly impossible to cure.

The body’s defense system automatically responds to the virus when it enters the system. This happens in the immune system through the use of antibodies. These are naturally produced by the body in response to any foreign invader. Antibodies bind to the antigenic sites of the outer-membrane proteins of the flu virus. This antigenic site is found on the hemagglutinin portion of the plasma membrane. The problem in treatment, is that antibodies will only bind to one type of hemagglutinin. This means that for each differing hemagglutinin, a new antibody must be developed by the immune system.

fluvirus-antigentic-characterization-medium
Figure 2: Shows the structure of an influenza virus highlighting the transmembrane protein hemagglutinin and neuraminidase as well as the antigenic sites. [4]
Every year the flu changes combinations and gathers mutations, meaning that the antigens you would have built up last year are now ineffective to the emerging strain. This is why the flu shot must be taken annually. With every flu shot you get, immunity is built up for that strain of influenza. This means that you would already have the antigens to fight that strain of the virus should you ever come in contact with it. If the vaccination is taken annually, immunity is built up for multiple strains of the virus, further protecting you not only from that year’s virus, but any repeating viruses.

Over time, you will build up your immunity to multiple strains of influenza so long as a mutation does not affect the antigenic sites. This is heavily beneficial with increasing age. As people get older, the effectiveness and efficiency of the immune system decreases. This is why it is highly important to get a flu shot every year. Complications with the flu virus more commonly take place in the elderly population. Infections such as pneumonia can occur and further threaten the lives of those who are more susceptible to infection. These complications are often times what causes mortality in flu infections as opposed to the virus itself.

The vaccination works by forcing your body to develop antibodies for a specific hemagglutinin antigen site. This is done by presenting the immune system with the virus in advance to build up antibodies. This can come in the form of an inactivated virus, or in an attenuated virus, meaning you may or may not be receiving an active version of the virus. In either case, the virus is modified to advance immunity without causing illness. The vaccination often times includes viruses from multiple strains of the flu to build immunity even further. With each vaccination, immunity for multiple strains of the virus is developed. However, the vaccination takes about two weeks to fully develop immunity in the body.

vaccine-effectiveness_v3
Figure 3: Shows the percent effectiveness of the flu vaccine by year form 2004-2018. [5]
The largest concern with flu vaccination is its history of variable effectiveness. There are years when the effectiveness is up to 60%, and others in which the effectiveness drops to as low at 17%. This causes a problem for many people. It seems that there is little reason to receive a shot for something that may not even deliver on its promise. New studies have started which may present a vaccination for all flu strains, but this development requires further testing before it can be produced and distributed. While there is no changing the effectiveness for the flu shot yet, there is an explanation for its variability. Every year, committees of scientists must predict which stain will break out. This prediction is based on many ever changing factors, and must be given up to a year in advance. This is so enough of the vaccination can be both developed and distributed in time to prevent the coming pandemic.

The trouble in predicting the virus breakout is that there are so many combinations of hemagglutinin and neuraminidase. Each of these combinations effect which antigens are needed for neutralization of the impending pandemic. While there are many factors that scientists take into account when predicting the next flu outbreak, there is no way to be one-hundred percent sure that they have chosen the right one. Even if the prediction for the outbreak is inaccurate, the shot is still beneficial for building immunity for future virus outbreaks.

Many misconceptions about the flu vaccine come from those who have received the vaccine and then developed an influenza infection anyway. This is primarily caused by the imprecise predictions of the scientists that year. It is also a possibility that they are in a minority that got a strain that was not covered in the vaccine. Despite many concerns, there is no reason not to get a shot. In receiving a vaccination, you are building your own immunity to flu strain, even if it is not the one that breaks out that year. Receiving the shot also protects those around you. The Influenza virus is responsible for upwards of 35,000 deaths each year in America alone [2]. By choosing to get a shot, you take a step towards preserving the health of those around you as well as your own. Influenza is a widely varied virus, but steps can be taken to protect ourselves and others from its detrimental effects.


References

  1. Brook, Deadly ‘Australian flu’ infecting thousands in UK (2018).
  2. Kim, Are We Prepared for the Next Pandemic Flu Virus? (2013).
  3. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Disease Burden of Influenza (2018).
  4. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Antigenic Characterization (2017).
  5. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Seasonal Influenza Vaccine Effectiveness, 2004-2018 (2018).
  6. Affelt, 5 Myths About the Flu Virus (2018).
  7. Maron, Beyond the Flu Shot (2018).
  8. Beil, One and Done (2017).
  9. Perry, Flu Fighters Building a Better Shot (2018).
  10. Leslie, Why last year’s flu vaccine didn’t work so well (2015).
  11. Cohen, A Once-in-a-Lifetime Flu Shot? (2013).
  12. Cohen, Nasty U.S. flu season continues to intensify (2018).
  13. Vogel, Blocking Flu at Its Core (2001).
  14. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Influenza (Flu) (2018).
  15. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Influenza A Subtypes and the Species Affected (2018).
  16. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, How the Flu Virus Can Change: “Drift” and “Shift” (2017).
  17. Riel, V. Munster, E. de Wit, G. Rimmelzwaan, R. Fouchier, A. Osterhaus, T. Kuiken, Human and Avian Influenza Viruses Target Different Cells in the Lower Respiratory Tract of Humans and Other Mammals (2007).
  18. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Key Facts About Seasonal Flu Vaccine (2018).
  19. Özaltin, O. Prokopyey, A. Schaefer, M. Roberts, Optimizing the Societal Benefits of the Annual Influenza Vaccine: A Stochastic Programming Approach (2011).
  20. Funk & Wagnalls New World Encyclopedia, Antigen (2017).
  21. Cohen, Llama Antibodies Inspire Gene Spray to Prevent all Flus (2018).

 

Leave a comment